Advertisement

Luxon and Hipkins both say they never lie as New Zealand’s second leaders’ debate turns on wages, jobs and gangs

Christopher Luxon and Chris Hipkins both told a Herald debate audience on Wednesday night that they have never lied in politics, then spent the next hour and a half accusing each other of getting the facts wrong. The second head-to-head of the campaign, hosted by Ryan Bridge at the NZME building in Auckland, came on the same evening six finance spokespeople traded insults in front of about 800 people in Queenstown. With the election on 7 November and the two big parties tied in the polls, neither night produced a knockout.

Bridge opened by asking each leader whether he had ever told a porkie. Hipkins won the coin toss and answered first. “Not deliberately, no,” he said, according to The Spinoff’s live coverage. He added that “On occasion, you’ll say something that you subsequently find is not true,” as Newsroom reported. Luxon said he had not lied either, but conceded a communication weakness. “You don’t always express yourself clearly or well enough, and sometimes you can do better,” he said, in remarks recorded by RNZ.

Advertisement

The honesty question hung over the night because Tuesday’s 1News Verian poll had National and Labour level on 28 per cent and both leaders on 20 per cent as preferred prime minister. Bridge put it bluntly. “Why are you guys doing so poorly?” he asked, as RNZ’s Craig McCulloch reported. Hipkins blamed general disillusionment with politics. Luxon pointed to a global problem of mainstream parties failing to deliver, but said that did not apply to his own government.

The sharpest early exchange came on the minimum wage. Bridge asked both men to pledge to lift it at the rate of inflation. Hipkins agreed. Luxon said “Yes, and that’s what we’ve more or less been doing.” Hipkins jumped in to point out the coalition has raised the minimum wage by less than inflation in each of its three years. Newsroom’s fact-check rated Luxon’s claim false, noting every April increase from 2024 to 2026 came in below the previous year’s consumer price inflation. Luxon also promised New World and Pak’nSave would be split apart next term “for sure,” before Bridge reminded him that National’s policy depends on a Commerce Commission recommendation.

Hipkins had his strongest stretch on jobs. He told the audience there are 48,000 more unemployed people today than when Luxon became prime minister, a figure Newsroom rated mostly true, with Stats NZ data showing unemployment rising from 122,000 in the December 2023 quarter to 171,000 in the June 2026 quarter. “You celebrate cutting jobs,” Hipkins told Luxon. “I want to create them.” On pay equity, he accused National of thinking women should settle for being paid less than men. Luxon countered that the economy is now growing faster than Australia, the United States and Britain, a claim Newsroom rated mostly true on annual figures but not on the latest quarter.

Advertisement

Luxon’s best material was his attack on Labour’s capital gains tax. “It’s going to kill our economy. It’s going to add a lot of costs. It’s going to slow down and suck out our recovery,” he said, before turning to the camera. “Mark my words, you are going to pay, New Zealand. You are going to pay.” Hipkins has pitched the tax as a way to fund health. He accused Luxon of lying about its reach. “This is why people don’t trust what you say,” Hipkins replied. Luxon’s own claim that Labour has “an $18 billion hole” in its plans was rated mostly false by Newsroom, which found Nicola Willis’s table of Labour costings rests on contestable assumptions.

Law and order gave Luxon his angriest moment. Green and Te Pāti Māori candidates were photographed this week at a gathering with Mongrel Mob members, and Luxon told Hipkins he had “tolerated your mates going off to a mongrel mob hang out.” Hipkins did not defend the visit. “No, I don’t condone it. I think it was a bad judgment,” he said, as the Herald reported. He went further and ruled out giving the police, corrections or justice portfolios to any Green or Te Pāti Māori MP in a Labour-led government, and said Chlöe Swarbrick would never be Treasurer. Luxon said “Frankly, I thought Chris’ Government was soft on crime.” McCulloch’s analysis noted that at 28 per cent Hipkins has limited leverage to dictate Cabinet seats to partners who could be a large share of his bloc.

Advertisement

Luxon for his part repeatedly ruled out Opportunity’s Qiulae Wong, the leader the polls place in the kingmaker seat. Asked whether he would rather sit in opposition than deal with her, he said “I’m going to be the prime minister.” Asked about sharing the top job with Winston Peters, his answer was “Hard no.” In the rule-in, rule-out round Luxon said he would wind up the Waitangi Tribunal, and ruled out scrapping the Climate Change Commission. Hipkins ruled out making Tribunal recommendations binding and put a voting age of 16 and compulsory te reo Māori in schools on the table. Asked about his own temperament after the August leadership challenge, Luxon said “I’m not a screamer, ranter, raver, shouter.”

RNZ’s transcript count showed how differently the two men played the night. Luxon spoke about 6255 words and Hipkins about 3958, with Hipkins sticking to short answers and interrupting more often. Both leaders declined to name a best friend from school. “Did neither of you have friends?” Bridge asked. The Herald’s own expert panel called it tight, and Newsroom’s Marc Daalder gave it to Hipkins by a slim margin. The two men meet once more next week.

In Queenstown the ASB Great Debate, moderated by TVNZ’s Jack Tame at the Queenstown Events Centre, was rowdier. Nicola Willis and Labour’s Barbara Edmonds clashed over Investment Boost, the tax write-off scheme Labour wants to scrap in favour of a small business package. Tame asked how a business like Coronet Peak would cope without it. “I don’t have to copy Nicola, we are two very different people,” Edmonds said to loud applause, according to RNZ’s Jo Moir. David Seymour watched the pair and said “It’s like two bald men fighting over a comb in the middle there.”

Shane Jones set the tone early with a complaint about his own government’s consenting regime. “Look at my beloved fast-track, it’s turned into a constipated beast,” he said. Willis drew the loudest boos of the night defending fast-tracked housing projects, and when Jones conceded infrastructure had received inadequate consideration, Swarbrick asked who was responsible for that. Seymour and Willis then fought openly over National’s plan to ask the Commerce Commission about breaking up the supermarket duopoly. “The whole thing’s nuts. It doesn’t stack up. Once you start with one industry, where does it stop?” Seymour said, as the Herald’s Derek Cheng reported. Jones told the crowd “Now you know what our Cabinet meetings are like.” Seymour shot back “One person has to bring the basic economics to Cabinet, that’s exactly what it’s like!”

Queenstown’s long-sought bed tax found a majority on stage. Edmonds, Swarbrick, Wong and Jones all said they would let the district levy one, which would give a Labour, Green and Opportunity bloc the numbers to change the law. “Is this a new coalition?” Swarbrick joked. Seymour argued a bed tax would take two years to set up and push up prices for every visitor, and that central government money, such as the $400 million from the International Visitor Levy that Luxon has promised councils, is the better route. All six were also asked whether they would join a cross-party review of superannuation. Seymour, Wong and Swarbrick said yes, Willis and Edmonds had agreed to it at the weekend, and Jones refused to join anything designed to lift the age of eligibility.

Willis went into the night having told RNZ she is interested in future business tax relief alongside personal tax cuts, but only once the books return to surplus, forecast for around 2028-29. “And I think over time, looking at that top-line corporate rate, yes, we’re not as competitive as we would like to be with the rest of the developed world,” she told Corin Dann. New Zealand First wants the company rate cut from 28 to 20 per cent for firms under $30 million turnover, while the Greens and Te Pāti Māori would lift it to 33 per cent for the largest companies.

With three weeks to go, the polls say the small parties will decide who governs. Our voting tool lets you compare where each party stands on tax, wages, housing and the supermarkets before you cast your vote. Did either Chris change your mind on Wednesday night, and which finance spokesperson would you trust with the books? Tell us in the comments.

This article was written by AI, briefed to report the facts, hopefully without some of the bias people bring to the job 🙂

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *