Stephen Fleming has been appointed head coach of England’s men’s Test team, handing New Zealand’s most successful Test captain the job of rebuilding a side he spent 14 years trying to beat. The England and Wales Cricket Board confirmed the appointment on Thursday, alongside news that Joe Root will return as Test captain.
The move means both of England’s cricket coaching jobs are now held by former New Zealand captains. Fleming takes the red ball side, while Brendon McCullum, the man he replaces in the Test role, stays on as England’s white ball coach. For a country that has spent most of its cricketing history being patronised by the English press, it is a curious sort of milestone.
Fleming will not actually start straight away. Sky Sports reported that assistant coach Marcus Trescothick will take interim charge for the three Test home series against Pakistan beginning on 19 August, with Fleming’s first matches in the job coming against South Africa in December. That leaves England without their new coach for the rest of the English summer, a gap that has already drawn criticism from cricket writers who see it as a wasted season.
“I’m incredibly excited to be joining England as Test coach,” Fleming said in the ECB announcement. “It’s one of the most prestigious coaching positions in world cricket.”
Rob Key, the ECB’s managing director of men’s cricket, said the board had landed a coach of rare standing. “Stephen Fleming is one of the most highly respected figures in cricket, and we are very fortunate that someone of his calibre is willing to take on the challenge of being the England Men’s Test Head Coach,” Key said.
Root’s return to the captaincy is the other half of the announcement. The 35 year old is England’s all time leading Test run scorer with 14,114 runs and previously led the side in 64 matches between 2017 and 2022, winning 27 of them. He stood down after a long run of poor results, then produced the most prolific stretch of batting of his career once the burden was gone. Harry Brook remains vice captain.
“It is a great honour and privilege to be asked to be England men’s Test captain again,” Root said. “I am excited to lead this next generation of players forward.”
The captaincy became vacant when Ben Stokes retired from international cricket earlier this month, confirming the end of a 15 year England career during the third Test against New Zealand at Trent Bridge. Stokes has since spoken about the physical toll of the past few years and the difficulty of the decision, describing it as the right one for him.
McCullum’s Test tenure ended on 12 July after four years. His record in the role was 27 wins, 20 defeats and two draws, a set of numbers that flatters an ending nobody enjoyed. England won 10 of their first 12 Tests under the approach the press christened Bazball, then lost 18 of the following 37, including seven of the last nine. A 4-1 Ashes defeat and then a 2-1 home series loss to New Zealand left the side seventh in the World Test Championship standings. RNZ reported McCullum saying he was gutted but that it was time for someone else to have a go.
Fleming brings a very different temperament to the job. Where McCullum’s England was built on declaring the risk was worth it, Fleming built his reputation on reading a game more carefully than anyone else on the field. He captained New Zealand in 80 Tests, a figure double that of Kane Williamson in second place, winning 28, losing 27 and drawing 25. He took the job in 1997 at the age of 23, the youngest captain New Zealand has ever had, and led series wins over India, England, the West Indies, Sri Lanka, Bangladesh and Zimbabwe with squads that were rarely the better team on paper.
As a player he made 7,172 runs in 111 Tests at an average of 40.06 with nine centuries, becoming the first New Zealander past 7,000 Test runs. The average is often held against him given how good he looked, and the nine hundreds against 46 fifties remains one of the odder lines in New Zealand cricket.
His coaching record is where the case for him sits. Fleming has coached the Chennai Super Kings since the Indian Premier League’s opening season in 2008 and won five titles with the franchise, in 2010, 2011, 2018, 2021 and 2023. He has also worked in the various franchise competitions that now fill the cricket calendar, building a reputation for handling large egos and short tournaments without fuss.
What he has not done is coach a Test team. Fleming arrives with no red ball international coaching experience at all, which is either the obvious objection or beside the point depending on how much weight you put on 80 Tests of captaincy. England have gambled before on a New Zealander with an unconventional record and got four years and a changed style out of it. The appointment was reported by the ICC and RNZ on Thursday.
For New Zealand supporters there is a small irony in all of this. The Black Caps beat England 2-1 in England this year, and the reward has been to lose the country’s most decorated Test captain and its most recognisable former captain to the opposition dressing room, permanently in one case and until the 2027 World Cup in the other.
What do you make of Fleming taking the England job? Tell us in the comments below.
This article was written by AI, briefed to report the facts, hopefully without some of the bias people bring to the job 🙂
Leave a Reply