Advertisement

Manage My Health breached privacy rules by importing hospital records for patients with no account, New Zealand Privacy Commissioner finds

Manage My Health breached New Zealand’s health privacy rules by importing Northland hospital records for patients who had no account on its portal, and by waiting two years before asking inactive users whether they still wanted their accounts, Privacy Commissioner Michael Webster has found.

The findings are in the second and final report of his inquiry into the December 2025 hack of the patient portal, released on Friday 30 October. Hackers stole copies of health documents belonging to around 100,000 patients from the portal’s “My Health Documents” module. The first report, on 27 May, found Manage My Health and Health NZ both failed to have good enough security. This one looks at how patients came to be affected and what the breach did to them.

Advertisement

Manage My Health had no contact details for about 47,000 of the affected people, and the commissioner says this “suggests that at least that number are likely to have been unaware of their accounts”. Health NZ managed to notify 19,497 of those 47,000, and final notifications were not completed until March.

The explanation lies in how records reached the portal. The report says about 91 per cent of affected people were from Northland, because of a unique arrangement between the old Northland District Health Board, now part of Health NZ, and Manage My Health to supply hospital discharge documents to patients. The commissioner’s media release rounds that figure to 90 per cent.

An automated match decided where those documents went, and the report’s summary describes two flaws in it. The first saved hospital information into accounts patients had never activated, and was corrected in January 2026. The second imported information where patients had no account at all, by matching it against records set up to share electronic health records between practitioners or to run the Easy Booking service.

Advertisement

Health NZ did not ask for that second match. The commissioner found Manage My Health was therefore acting on its own account, and that it broke rules 1 and 2(1) of the Health Information Privacy Code, which govern why information is collected and where it comes from. The report says “there was clearly no valid purpose for importing information into the portal when patients could not access the records”. It also accepts that the company did not use the information. Manage My Health has formally confirmed it has deleted everything except information in activated accounts, including from backups, and the commissioner says he is “satisfied that MMH has fully remediated the problem”.

The second breach concerns old accounts. At the time of the hack, Manage My Health only began its dormant account process after 24 months of inactivity, which the commissioner found breached rule 9 of the code, the rule on how long information can be kept. The company has since cut that to 12 months for patients not attached to a medical centre using its service, but the longer period still applies to patients who are. The report recommends cutting that to 12 months too, and deleting accounts that have not been activated after three months.

Advertisement

The commissioner says both Manage My Health and Health NZ met their duty to tell his office, with the company doing so within the expected 72 hours. It first described the breach as not involving serious harm, and put that down to an administrative error, an explanation the report accepts while noting Manage My Health is far from the only agency to have made that mistake. The commissioner has “reservations” about how long it took to tell some individuals, but says this does not automatically mean the law was broken. That would have to be decided on individual complaints, and his office has received around 50.

The part of the report that reaches well beyond health is its advice to any organisation running customer accounts. The commissioner says he generally expects a check-in after 12 months of inactivity unless a law or specific reason requires the information to be kept. A customer who never finishes registering has not authorised further collection and storage of their information. A contractor that makes a design decision its client did not agree to becomes independently responsible for it under privacy law. Poor processes for identifying affected people are no excuse for late notification.

The report also lists what a breach plan should cover, including ready access to customer contact details, a way to reach key people over holidays, and outside legal and technical help that can be called in. This breach was discovered on 30 December. “It’s going to be a lot more stressful for your customers and your staff if you have to create your crisis management playbook as you respond to the crisis”, Mr Webster said.

GP practices and their representative bodies have reported some patients now ask for physical rather than digital copies of information, and the commissioner says the breach has significantly damaged trust in health portals. In Northland, the commissioner says, the concentration of affected patients meant “a disproportionate impact on Māori patients, whānau and health services in that region”.

Health NZ cancelled the contract to supply hospital information through Manage My Health on 27 May and has temporarily gone back to paper for most of it. Its action plan, published on 24 July, proposes a new digital service that is not tied to one vendor, offered first in Northland. The commissioner recommends direct engagement with the Northland community and health providers as a central part of that work, and face-to-face meetings between both organisations and the community. Feedback recorded from a meeting in Whangārei raised wider concerns. “The pace of government digitisation was a real cause for concern”, the report says, and “AI was flagged as an emerging risk that could amplify existing vulnerabilities if governance frameworks are not strengthened now.”

Responding to the report, Health NZ said, according to RNZ, “The Phase Two report does not identify any new privacy breaches by Health NZ and confirms we have met our legal obligations following the incident, including notifying the Privacy Commissioner and affected people.” Manage My Health’s news page carried no statement on the second report when Newswire checked on Monday, though the report says the company had a chance to comment on relevant findings before publication. In a statement on 27 May, responding to the first report, the company said “We apologise for this occurrence and for the impact it has had on those affected.”

The inquiry is now closed, but the compliance notices issued on 23 September to both organisations will be managed as they set out. The commissioner’s office has information for people affected by the breach. Separately, Manage My Health warned on 28 October about phishing emails offering a $75 refund in its name, and says it “will never ask you to sign in through an email link to claim a refund”.

Does your business have a plan for telling customers about a data breach, and how long do you keep accounts nobody uses? Share your thoughts in the comments below.

This article was written by AI, briefed to report the facts, hopefully without some of the bias people bring to the job 🙂

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *