Advertisement

Card surcharges are now the main reason New Zealanders avoid contactless, Payments NZ survey finds

Card surcharges have become the main reason New Zealanders give for not paying by contactless, according to new research released today by Payments NZ, the industry governance body for the country’s core payment systems. Four in ten people surveyed said they had changed how they pay in the past year to avoid fees or surcharges.

For a café, shop or trade business that adds a percentage at the till, the finding is a plain signal. Some customers are reacting to surcharges by paying another way, whether that means inserting their card, paying cash or using a bank transfer.

Advertisement

The Payments NZ Consumer Research 2026 report surveyed a nationally representative sample of 1,000 New Zealanders aged 18 and over in June, using online market panels. According to Payments NZ, “Surcharges have also overtaken security concerns as the leading reason respondents give for not using contactless payments.” The report says this is the first time surcharges have topped that list, but it does not publish the percentage behind the ranking.

What the survey found

Contactless is still the everyday default. At least 84 per cent of respondents said they use contactless payments in store at least sometimes, rising to 93 per cent of 18 to 34 year olds. But warmth towards it has cooled. The share who said they love or like contactless fell from 65 per cent in 2024 to 57 per cent this year, while the share who feel neutral rose from 19 to 26 per cent.

The change is sharpest among older customers. Use of contactless by people aged 65 and over has dropped from 79 per cent in 2022 to 69 per cent in 2026, and in that age group 35 per cent now say they like it while 34 per cent say they dislike it. The report suggests this may reflect growing awareness of surcharges, or that contactless has simply become an expected part of paying rather than something people feel strongly about.

Advertisement

Cost pressure runs through the results. Forty six per cent of respondents reported at least one sign of financial stress in the past 12 months, most commonly delaying or avoiding a purchase (32 per cent). Separately, 40 per cent said they had changed how they pay to avoid fees or surcharges, with examples in the question including avoiding contactless, choosing cash or using a bank transfer.

Other shifts matter for how a business sets up its counter and checkout. A quarter of respondents now prefer to pay by smartphone for everyday purchases, up from 15 per cent in 2024, while the share preferring cash has held at 11 per cent since 2022. Online, cards remain the most preferred way to pay at 60 per cent. Fraud is front of mind too, with 76 per cent saying they are concerned about fraud and scams when paying and 29 per cent saying they had changed how they pay because of that risk. When asked to rank what matters in a new way to pay, having no extra charges or fees came second overall, behind safety and security.

Advertisement

“New Zealanders are embracing more digital ways to pay, but the fundamentals remain consistent. People want payments that are safe, affordable, accessible and easy to use,” Payments NZ chief executive Steve Wiggins said in the release.

Where the surcharge rules stand

Surcharging is still legal for in-store card payments in New Zealand. The Government’s bill to ban surcharges on in-store EFTPOS, Visa and Mastercard payments has not passed. The latest version of the Retail Payment System (Ban on Merchant Surcharges) Amendment Bill is still the one reported back by Parliament’s Finance and Expenditure Committee on 13 November 2025, and the bill was among those left waiting on the Order Paper when Parliament rose for the 7 November election. If it ever became law, it would take effect one month after Royal assent.

The committee’s report shows why the bill split opinion among the people it would affect most. ACT said in its differing view that the bill as drafted “may have unintended consequences” and “could create higher prices for consumers, undermine existing free payments systems (e.g., EFTPOS)”. Labour said it agreed consumers should pay the shelf price but added, “we do not support adding costs to small business.” Newswire covered the stalled ban and the competing arguments in more detail in June.

In the meantime the Commerce Commission’s guidance applies. Its page on making and accepting payments says every business should offer at least one payment option without a surcharge, that any surcharge should only cover the extra cost compared with that option, and that EFTPOS for in-person payments should not carry one. “We would expect any in-person surcharge rates reduce toward 1% or lower for most businesses,” the Commission says.

Card fee caps

The wholesale cost underneath many surcharges has already fallen. The Commission’s interchange fee regulation lowered the limits on interchange fees, which the Commission describes as the largest component of the merchant service fee a business pays to accept Mastercard and Visa. It says interchange made up 60 per cent of merchant service fees in 2024. The new limits took effect on 1 December 2025 for New Zealand issued cards and 1 May 2026 for overseas cards.

Under the Mastercard and Visa Interchange Fee Network Standard 2025, the cap on a domestic contactless payment with a personal card is 0.20 per cent on a debit card and 0.30 per cent on a credit card. For a card that is inserted rather than tapped, the cap is 0.00 per cent on debit and 0.30 per cent on credit. Online payments are capped at 0.60 per cent on debit and 0.70 per cent on credit.

Here is how that looks on a $20 coffee and muffin paid by tapping a New Zealand debit card. A 1.5 per cent surcharge adds 30 cents. The interchange on that payment can be no more than 4 cents. The business’s full cost is higher than that, because a merchant service fee also includes scheme fees, a transaction fee and the provider’s margin, and pricing plans differ. That is why the Commission encourages businesses to work out their effective merchant service fee rate and compare providers, rather than assuming an old surcharge still matches today’s cost.

For a small business deciding what to do, the survey and the rules point the same way. A surcharge set well above the real cost of a contactless payment sits outside what the Commission expects and, on this evidence, pushes some customers to pay another way. Businesses that keep surcharging can check their latest fee statement against the rate they charge, and make sure customers have a clear way to pay without a surcharge, such as EFTPOS. The rules are set out on the Commerce Commission’s retail payments pages.

Do you add a surcharge at your counter, have you dropped it, or have your customers started paying differently this year? Tell us how it is working in your business in the comments below.

This article was written by AI, briefed to report the facts, hopefully without some of the bias people bring to the job 🙂

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *