Advertisement

Joan Wiffen, the Hawke’s Bay woman who found New Zealand’s dinosaurs

Joan Wiffen's theropod reconstruction

One winter afternoon in 1972, in a small house near the coast at Haumoana, a middle-aged woman in her fifties spread an old geological survey map out on the kitchen table and began reading it the way other people read novels.

She had no university degree. She had finished only a couple of years of secondary school. Her formal scientific training amounted to one term of a geology night class in Napier, taken on her husband’s behalf because he was too sick to attend and the fee had already been paid. She had two children, a small Hawke’s Bay farm to run, and a part-time job that depended mostly on hard work and asparagus. Her name was Joan Wiffen.

Advertisement

The map she was reading was a 1958 oil-company survey of the Hawke’s Bay back country. Most of it was a pretty patchwork — pink, mauve, mustard yellow — coloured by rock type. But buried in tiny print, in a paragraph of marginalia almost nobody had ever bothered to read, was a single sentence about an obscure stream bed in the Te Hoe Valley, deep in the bush behind Wairoa. The note said the rocks there were Cretaceous, that the strata were brackish, and that earlier surveyors had reported what they had charmingly called reptilian remains.

Wiffen later said the words came off the page like a buzzing neon sign. She knew exactly what “reptilian remains” in Cretaceous rocks meant. She had been reading her way through the small palaeontology section at the Hastings Public Library for years. It meant the kind of creatures the rest of the world had been digging up since the 1820s: ancient sea reptiles, possibly dinosaurs, certainly something old and big and weird and not, as she had been taught at school, supposed to exist in New Zealand at all.

It took her family about six months to work out exactly where the stream was, who owned the land, and how to get a permit to walk on it. When they finally did get there, Joan, her husband Pont, and their teenage children scrambled down a steep bush track and waded out into a small icy creek called the Mangahouanga, in the western fringes of the Te Urewera. The stream bed was full of round grey concretions — calcareous sandstone boulders the size of footballs, the size of beachballs, the size of bathtubs. Joan picked one up. It was crusted with belemnites and shark teeth and fish scales, the marine life of an ancient lagoon, all turned to stone.

Advertisement

Three years later, in this same stream, hundreds of metres below the rim of an impossibly remote valley, she would prise a small, ridged, dirty-grey vertebra out of the rock. It would change New Zealand’s understanding of its own deep past. By the time she was finished, this self-taught Hawke’s Bay woman would have led the discovery of every dinosaur known to have lived on these islands, established a polar dinosaur fauna where nobody had thought one could exist, co-authored or authored more than a dozen scientific papers, been awarded an honorary doctorate, become a CBE, and quietly built a parallel scientific career that several professional palaeontologists later said was simply better than theirs.

The girl who was told higher education was wasted on women

Joan Pederson was born on 4 February 1922 in Hawke’s Bay. Her childhood was split between Havelock North and the rough hill country of the King Country, where her father took the family during the Depression. He was a strict man. He believed, and said so out loud, that higher education was a waste of money on girls. Joan was pulled out of school at fifteen.

Advertisement

She remembered, much later, walking the King Country hills with her father and pointing out the seashells embedded in cliffs hundreds of metres above the Tasman. Why are they up there? she asked. Because the land has come up out of the sea, he said. He could not have known what he had started.

In February 1938 she turned sixteen. By the time she was eighteen, the war had reached out and pulled her into uniform. She joined the Women’s Auxiliary Air Force and served for six years, working as a medical clerk, a filter-room plotter watching aircraft tracks on a map table, and a runner carrying classified files between offices. It was the first work she had done that involved patterns and inference and large quantities of strange data, and she liked it enormously.

In 1953, when she was thirty-one, she married Montagu Arthur Wiffen, known to everyone as Pont. He was a radio technician for the local broadcasting station and an electronics tinkerer of the old New Zealand school, the kind of man who could fix anything if you gave him a multimeter and a roll of solder. They bought a small farm. They renovated a derelict farmhouse, raised two children — Chris and Anne — built greenhouses, planted asparagus, kept a few sheep, and quietly absorbed the daily reality of postwar rural New Zealand: small budget, no inherited capital, plenty of land, plenty of weather, no nonsense.

In any other century she would have stayed there. The thing that pried Joan Wiffen’s life open was a children’s encyclopaedia, an evening class she did not want, and an Australian roadside stall selling fossils for fifty cents apiece.

How a country wife became a citizen scientist

The encyclopaedia came first. By the early 1960s the children were old enough to ask difficult questions about animals and rocks, and Joan, who had answered most household questions by buying a book, started bringing home natural history volumes for them. The whole family ended up reading them. Around 1961 they joined the local Hawke’s Bay Rock and Mineral Club, which was at the time mostly an excuse for retirees to drive into the back blocks of the Ruahine and the Kaweka with rock hammers and come home with agates.

Pont enrolled in a night class on geology in Napier. He paid his fee, attended the first class, then was hit by an illness serious enough to keep him out of the rest of the course. Joan, who was not going to let a paid-up tuition fee go to waste, attended in his place. She liked it. She liked it more than she had liked anything since the air force.

The second turn of the screw came in 1968. Pont, recovered, took the family on the long-promised trip to Queensland. They drifted around inland Australia for several months, fossicking for opal and topaz and any other rocks the kids could carry home. At some unremarkable rural stall, Joan bought a small grey trilobite for fifty cents. It was the first fossil she had ever held that was clearly the body of a once-living animal. It was 400 million years old. She was hooked.

She came back to New Zealand and started reading her way through every palaeontology book she could borrow. She studied the geological survey maps. She wrote polite letters to specialists. She also, by her own account, decided fairly early on that what she really wanted to find was a dinosaur.

This was, in 1970, considered a slightly mad ambition. Every New Zealand schoolchild was taught that during the age of dinosaurs the country had been entirely beneath the sea. The South Island had given up marine reptile bones — plesiosaurs and mosasaurs, fossils of long-necked and lizardy things that had hunted in the Cretaceous oceans — but no land animals. The orthodoxy, repeated in every textbook, was that New Zealand had been a long thin smear of sea floor while Tyrannosaurus and its cousins were trampling everywhere else. Even Charles Fleming, the most senior fossil scientist in the country, had begun in 1967 to suggest very gently that this might not actually be true. Nobody had gone looking.

The map and the stream

The map that opened the next thirty years of Joan Wiffen’s life was a Don Haw oil-company survey from 1958. It mentioned reptile bones in the Te Hoe Valley. The Wiffens followed the lead. The family’s first trip into the Mangahouanga was in 1972, on foot, with packs and tea bags and a notebook. They found marine fossils almost immediately — fish scales, fish teeth, shark teeth, belemnite guards, the occasional ammonite — locked into the round grey concretions that the stream had been spitting out of the bedrock for thousands of years.

In 1973, on one of their return trips, Pont prised loose what turned out to be a vertebra from a plesiosaur. It was the first fossil bone of an extinct vertebrate animal the family had ever found. Joan could not formally identify it; she sent a cast to a specialist, who confirmed what it was. The Wiffens went back. And back. And back.

The Mangahouanga is not an easy place to work. It is not a stream you visit. It is a stream you assault. The drive from Napier is roughly a hundred kilometres on tarseal and then logging road, twisting through the western Hawke’s Bay hill country toward the Te Urewera; the last section is a foot-track that drops down a cliff face by way of an aluminium ladder Joan had scavenged from somewhere and bolted to the rock. From the bottom of the ladder, Joan, Pont and an accumulating circle of fellow enthusiasts — Trevor Crabtree, who became the most committed of them, plus a rotating cast of Hawke’s Bay rock club members and friends — would ford the icy water on guide ropes, hammer at split boulders with a converted chainsaw, and identify, mark, cut and carry out fossil-bearing rocks, one at a time.

Over the next two decades, by the New Zealand Geographic count, the team backpacked roughly a hundred tonnes of fossil-bearing rock out of that valley. By hand. The journalist Vaughan Yarwood, who walked the track with Joan in 1993, watched her, then seventy-one and recovering from flu, pause against a tree to catch her breath on the climb out. She had done the trip dozens of times.

The home end of the operation was even more unlikely. The rock-bearing concretions were taken back to a row of garages and back yards in Napier and worked over slowly with hand tools, rock saws, hardware-shop chisels, and baths of glacial acetic acid that the Wiffens bought, decanted and stored themselves. The acid would dissolve the limestone matrix without harming the bone. The bone, once exposed, would be sealed under coats of acrylic resin painted on with a small brush. Then the acid would go to work again. Some specimens took years.

“Acid is a wonderful tool,” Joan said in 1993, “but very expensive and destructive.”

The 1975 vertebra

The fossil that broke the orthodoxy of New Zealand palaeontology was not, when Joan first saw it, particularly impressive. It was a small, lozenge-shaped chunk of bone embedded in a concretion she had carried out of the Mangahouanga sometime around 1974 or 1975 — the dates blur in her own accounts because the recovery work took years. By the time it was clean, after months of acid baths in a Napier shed, it was a vertebra perhaps the size of a man’s fist, with a peculiar set of features Joan had never seen on the marine reptile bones she now knew well.

It had a flat, slightly hollowed face, where the marine reptile vertebrae she had handled were deeply cupped. It had ridges in the wrong places. It had what looked like attachment scars for muscles that did not match a swimming animal. She suspected it was from a land creature. She suspected, in fact, what it really was. But she could not say so. There was no vertebrate palaeontologist in New Zealand qualified to confirm it.

So she got on a plane.

In 1979 Joan and Pont flew to Brisbane with a parcel of fossils and made their way to the Queensland Museum. There they found a young, recently arrived American scientist called Ralph Molnar, who had just left a job in Sydney to take over the museum’s vertebrate fossil collection and to deal with the public who walked in carrying odd things. Molnar wrote later, in a tribute he published in New Zealand Geographic after Joan’s death, that the moment he started talking to the Wiffens he could tell they were different from most museum visitors. “They actually knew what they were talking about,” he wrote. They knew, for instance, the difference between a dinosaur and a marine reptile. They knew the strata. They knew the literature.

Molnar examined the vertebra. He took photographs. He compared it against known Australian theropod material. And then he confirmed what Joan had already privately worked out: it was a caudal vertebra — a tail bone — from a small carnivorous theropod dinosaur. It was the first piece of a dinosaur that had ever been found on New Zealand soil. It was, in conservative terms, between 70 and 80 million years old.

For the first time since the science had been established, the question of whether New Zealand had ever hosted dinosaurs had a definitive answer. Yes. They had been here.

The conference where she was not allowed to speak

The Fifth Gondwana Symposium met in Wellington in 1980. It was the major scientific gathering of the year for everyone in the southern hemisphere who studied the long history of the great southern supercontinent. The discovery of dinosaurs in New Zealand was, by any objective measure, the most consequential local result in the field for a generation.

Joan was not allowed to present it. She had no doctorate. She had no university position. The convening committee, with what their successors might politely call extreme caution, decided the discovery should be announced by an accredited academic. Ralph Molnar flew over from Brisbane and read out the paper instead.

Joan sat in the audience.

She wrote later, in her 1991 memoir Valley of the Dragons, that the response was “a thunderous silence.” The New Zealand scientific community, she said, treated the news with “a general lack of interest or understanding” of what dinosaurs in New Zealand actually meant for the country’s geological and evolutionary story. The public, when the newspapers caught up, was much more enthusiastic. Schoolchildren wrote her letters. Reporters arrived at the farm.

The professional palaeontologists who worked with her over the next twenty years, however, were almost universally generous about her, even those who would have preferred the work to be done by people with letters after their names. She co-authored papers with Molnar. She corresponded with French specialists, with American ones, with Otago Museum staff, with the team at what was then the Institute of Geological and Nuclear Sciences, where her finds were eventually deposited for permanent curation. She wrote politely. She referenced exhaustively. She made painstaking casts of every important specimen so they could go overseas for comparison without risk to the original.

The shoestring laboratory

The most striking thing about the Mangahouanga operation, even thirty years later, is how absurdly under-resourced it was. By the early 1990s, when Vaughan Yarwood profiled the group for New Zealand Geographic, total grant funding to the Hawke’s Bay Palaeontological Group across two decades amounted to roughly six hundred dollars. “My piggy bank,” Joan once said, was what determined whether she could afford to fly to a conference.

The toolkit was not much better. A converted chainsaw with a tungsten-tipped blade for slabbing concretions in the stream. A row of plastic drums of acetic acid in a Napier yard. A miniature pneumatic chisel — what palaeontologists call an air scribe — bought secondhand and replaced when it wore out. A dental drill. Tubs of dental resin. The library at Hastings. The Hawke’s Bay public phone box at the Te Hoe roadhead, and later the Hawke’s Bay Palaeontology Group’s pair of huts at the same roadhead, fourteen kilometres from the nearest landline and forty-five from sealed road. Beside the second hut, what one journalist called “possibly the country’s most remote flushing toilet.”

The list of finds those tools recovered, however, is the list that rewrote a textbook.

After the 1975 theropod vertebra came an ankylosaur in 1988 — a low-slung armoured plant-eater the size of a small car. Then a hypsilophodont, a fast bipedal herbivore something like a Cretaceous gazelle. Then a second, larger theropod, an allosaur-grade carnivore around nine metres long. Then mosasaur and plesiosaur skulls in extraordinary condition, including one nearly complete elasmosaur skull, one of barely a dozen in the world. Then, in 1986, a delicate, layered hollow bone Trevor Crabtree had spotted in his own back yard rock pile and which Joan, after months of careful preparation and an international consultation, identified as the wing bone of a pterosaur. New Zealand had had not just dinosaurs; it had had a fauna. The 1986 pterosaur was followed by a juvenile shoulder blade Joan herself recovered, confirming the find.

In 1990 she described and named two new species of mosasaur, Rikisaurus tehoensis and Mosasaurus flemingi, the second after the geologist who had nearly forty years earlier suggested New Zealand might one day yield this kind of bone. In 1994 she and Molnar published a major review paper, A late Cretaceous polar dinosaur fauna from New Zealand. In 1999, at the age of seventy-seven, she found in a tributary of the Te Hoe River the vertebra of a titanosaur — a long-necked sauropod, the largest type of land animal that has ever lived. The species had been at the edge of an icy, polar continent at the bottom of the Cretaceous world.

Why this was actually new science

It is easy to read the Wiffen story as a charming yarn about a country housewife with a hammer. That is not what was happening at Mangahouanga. What Joan and her team were excavating was a complete late Cretaceous coastal lagoon ecosystem from a piece of the world nobody had previously studied: the eastern, polar margin of Gondwana, on a fragment of continental crust that would later become Aotearoa New Zealand.

The Mangahouanga fossils sit in what geologists call the Tahora Formation, deposited around 80 to 70 million years ago in the latest Cretaceous. At the time, the New Zealand land mass — already in the process of pulling away from the rest of Gondwana — sat at a latitude of roughly 70 degrees south. It was in the polar zone. The local climate was cool to cold. The sun did not rise for months at a time in winter. There were river-fed estuaries, low forest of Nothofagus-type beech, ferns, and a coastline that Joan’s team have traced through more than twenty kilometres of stream-bed cuttings.

That is the science. New Zealand’s dinosaurs were not tropical. They were polar dinosaurs. They lived in long winter dark and cool summer light, in the kind of ecosystem that until quite recently nobody believed dinosaurs could even tolerate. The Mangahouanga material, alongside contemporary discoveries from Dinosaur Cove in Victoria, Alaska, and the Antarctic Peninsula, helped reset the global picture. Dinosaurs were warmer-blooded, more adaptable, and far more cosmopolitan than the textbooks of Joan’s childhood had ever conceded.

The Mangahouanga material also forced a rethink of the timing of New Zealand’s separation from Gondwana. Some of the dinosaur remains in the Te Hoe rocks are younger than the moment when the Tasman Sea opened and the Zealandia plate began drifting east. That meant some of them had been on a plate that was already an island. That meant that for at least fifteen million years, until the global extinction at the end of the Cretaceous, New Zealand had its own isolated dinosaur fauna, evolving in its own peculiar direction, exactly the way the islands’ birds and tuatara would later do.

Plesiosaur work Joan helped lead also produced one of the more surprising marine biology results of the period: by examining the microstructure of fossil bones, she and her collaborators showed that some plesiosaurs began life as juveniles in coastal estuaries before moving offshore as adults. This was a fact about behaviour, not just anatomy, and it had implications for how plesiosaurs were studied everywhere in the world. Ralph Molnar described it as a discovery with “broader implications for those of us elsewhere in the world.” Coming from a man who at that point ran the vertebrate fossil collection of an entire Australian state museum, that was a significant compliment.

A note on names

The valley Joan worked in is sometimes spelled Mangahouanga and sometimes Maungahouanga, and even Joan’s own books used both. The stream is properly the Mangahouanga, a tributary of the Te Hoe River, which in turn runs into the Mohaka. Maunga means mountain in te reo Māori. Manga means a stream or branch. Within bellowing distance, as Yarwood put it, was a place called Maungataniwha — “mountain of the dragons.” Joan was struck by the coincidence. So was anyone who ever walked the bush track at dusk with a pack of fossil bones on their back.

Whether early Māori had ever found exposed bones in the Mangahouanga concretions and recognised them for what they were is unknown. Joan thought it was at least possible. The hill country around the stream had long been settled, gardened and hunted. The cliffs and erosion scars that Joan was working in 1972 were almost certainly not the same scars that had been visible a hundred years earlier. Geology is a slow churn, but the Te Hoe is steep, wet country, and floods rearrange the river bed every few years. In 1985, after a regional uplift earthquake, the Mangahouanga rose nine metres in places. Joan lost promising specimens; the land also brought new ones to the surface. After Cyclone Bola in 1988, fresh boulders delivered the ankylosaur.

Recognition, finally

By the 1990s the same scientific community that had refused to let Joan present at the Gondwana symposium was queueing up to hand her things. In 1994 Massey University awarded her an honorary Doctor of Science. The same year, the Royal Society of New Zealand presented her with its Science and Technology Bronze Medal. In the 1995 New Year Honours, Queen Elizabeth II appointed her a Commander of the Order of the British Empire for services to science.

In 2004, the United States Society of Vertebrate Paleontology awarded her the Morris Skinner Award, given for outstanding contributions of unusual significance to vertebrate palaeontology by a non-professional. The citation made the obvious point. Joan Wiffen, working out of a Hawke’s Bay shed, had contributed more to the field, on a per-dollar and per-publication basis, than most professional palaeontologists ever do.

She published two books for the public. Valley of the Dragons, in 1991, told the story of the early years at Mangahouanga and was part autobiography, part field journal, part popular palaeontology. Dinosaur New Zealand, written in 2002 with Geoffrey Cox, was a full illustrated catalogue of every fossil reptile then known from the New Zealand record. The same year, the Auckland production company Red Sky made a documentary, The Lost Dinosaurs of New Zealand, which played in cinemas and was screened on TVNZ. By that point Joan was eighty.

In 2017, eight years after her death, the Royal Society Te Apārangi included her in its 150 Women in 150 Words list, marking the contributions of women to knowledge in New Zealand.

Her hometown of Havelock North named a small street after her. Joan Wiffen Avenue runs off Te Mata Road. It is not a long street.

The husband who carried the rocks

One of the easier mistakes to make about Joan is to imagine her as a lone genius. She would have hated that. The Mangahouanga work was a genuine team operation, and Joan was scrupulous about saying so in print. Pont, who had been the original geology student, did most of the heavy lifting with her in the early years. He carried packs. He helped maintain the home laboratory. He was, by family accounts, completely uninterested in being the public face of any of it. He died in 2002.

Trevor Crabtree, the possum-hunter and deerstalker who had joined the Hawke’s Bay Rock and Mineral Club in the 1970s, found the pterosaur, the fish skull, the ankylosaur and an unknown number of other key specimens. The pair of huts at the Te Hoe roadhead were as much his construction as anyone’s. Other regulars, on rotation, included Howard Hughes, Mike Pole, and a string of teenage helpers who were sometimes hers and sometimes other people’s children. The work was slow, physical and unglamorous. It was rural Hawke’s Bay applied to the deep past.

It was also, quietly, scientifically modern. Joan was an early and aggressive adopter of microscopic bone-section histology. She was generous in sharing material with overseas teams. She kept casts. She kept careful records. The fossils she recovered are now part of the National Paleontology Collection at GNS Science in Lower Hutt, where they remain available to anyone with a research case for studying them. Many are still being worked on. The 1999 titanosaur material has spawned papers a quarter of a century later.

The science she did, in plain English

If you were to make a list of what New Zealand science would not know without Joan Wiffen, it would include all of the following. That dinosaurs lived in this country at all. That at least two carnivorous theropods, an ankylosaur, a hypsilophodont and a sauropod were among them. That a pterosaur with a four-metre wingspan flew over the Te Hoe estuary. That at least three named species of plesiosaur and mosasaur lived in the coastal waters. That juvenile plesiosaurs began life inshore and moved offshore as adults. That dinosaurs in this part of the world coped with polar conditions. That the Cretaceous fauna of New Zealand was sufficiently distinct to support the conclusion that the country had been a separate evolutionary stage for at least the last fifteen million years before the great extinction.

Each of these results, in isolation, would represent a respectable career for an academic palaeontologist. Together, accomplished outside the academy, on private money, with no laboratory, no graduate students and no institutional infrastructure, they constitute an achievement that the modern New Zealand science system would, on current funding rules, be largely incapable of producing.

That last fact is one of the quieter inheritances Joan left her successors. Almost all of the original Mangahouanga fieldwork was done by people who would today not qualify for a Marsden grant. The Department of Conservation policy work she did later in life — sitting on advisory committees on the protection of fossil sites — was a direct response to her own experience. Mangahouanga, when she found it, was on private land with no formal protection. It is now widely understood as the most important Cretaceous vertebrate site in the country.

The last decade

By the early 2000s Joan was in her late seventies and beginning to slow down. She still made occasional trips to the stream. She wrote. She corresponded. She gave talks at primary schools. She had a particular fondness for the questions seven-year-olds asked her, because in her experience seven-year-olds were the only group of human beings who took dinosaurs as seriously as she did.

Pont died in 2002. Joan moved into Hastings. She kept a small workshop. She kept writing. She was widely interviewed in her last years and was uniformly unfussed about her own role. To one journalist she summed up her decades of discovery as simply keeping on turning over rocks. To another, asked whether she minded being called the Dinosaur Lady, she said, drily, that she preferred Dinosaur Woman.

She did not particularly recommend her own path to younger women. Get a degree, she said. Get the qualifications. Sit at the table on equal footing. Do not start where I had to start.

She died on 30 June 2009 in Hastings Hospital, aged eighty-seven. Tributes came from Australia, Britain, France, Canada and the United States. Her papers and casts were donated to GNS Science. The fossils she had pulled out of the Mangahouanga stream, packed in numbered drawers in Lower Hutt, are now part of the public scientific inheritance of the country.

What she actually changed

The geology textbooks New Zealand schoolchildren had read for the better part of a century said the country had been underwater while dinosaurs ruled the planet. It was a tidy story, and it was also wrong. The land that became New Zealand was very much above the waves at the end of the Cretaceous, hosting forests and rivers and at least four families of dinosaurs, and it had been a separate stage for so long that some of those animals were well on the way to becoming uniquely local lineages when an asteroid struck Mexico and most of them died.

None of this was unknowable. The bones had been sitting in a remote Hawke’s Bay stream bed for tens of millions of years. The clue had been buried in tiny print on a 1958 oil-company map. What was needed was somebody who would read the map carefully, follow it into the bush, work patiently for thirty years, and not be dissuaded by the fact that everyone with a doctorate was telling her she was wasting her time.

That person turned out to be a Hawke’s Bay grandmother who had left school at fifteen, served six years in uniform, raised two children on a small farm, picked up an interest in geology on her husband’s behalf, and at the age of fifty had decided, with extreme calm, that she was going to find New Zealand’s dinosaurs.

She did. They are hers.

Sources and further reading

More from the Great New Zealanders series

This is part of Newswire’s Great New Zealanders series, which profiles people whose lives shaped this country. Other recent profiles include Beatrice Tinsley, the New Plymouth girl who rewrote the universe, Roy Kerr, Nancy Wake and Charles Upham.

Have something to add

Did your family know Joan Wiffen, or anyone in the Hawke’s Bay Palaeontology Group? Have you walked the Mangahouanga track yourself? Did you grow up reading Valley of the Dragons or watching The Lost Dinosaurs of New Zealand? We would love to hear from you in the comments below.

This article was written by AI, briefed to report the facts, hopefully without some of the bias people bring to the job 🙂

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *